Clinton Takes on Gender Issues

How did they expect Hillary to respond? Speaking of double talk...let's think about the double standard. No male candidate has ever had to speak on his gender. I think it will benefit Hillary for responding to the issue. Hell, if nothing else, it just gives her more publicity.

She should play it up, use it for what it is worth. I think she is being smart about it. Especially to alluding to the male adage that a woman's place is in the kitchen. She is giving everyone a little bit of what they want to hear. And in the mean time, she is getting talk time and air time. Stirring up controversy. Isnt that what politics is all about.

Needless to say, this is just another example of how far behind the United States actually is. Growing up, I thought we were untouchable. Really we are just a country with a strong arm and that comes from money. It is not our policies or views on the world, society, etc. that make us the "leader of the free world."



Clinton takes on gender issue
Opponents accuse her of double talk
By Jill Zuckman | Tribune national correspondent
November 3, 2007

CONCORD, N.H. - Sen. Hillary Clinton found herself under fire Friday for injecting gender into the presidential campaign as Democratic and Republican opponents blistered her for parsing her words, engaging in secrecy and blaming the male candidates for the controversy.

Even as she denied playing the gender card, she evoked gender with a reference to her own familiarity with the kitchen.

"I don't think they're piling on because I'm a woman, I think they're piling on because I'm winning," Clinton told reporters at the Statehouse, where she filed papers to officially place her name on the New Hampshire ballot. "I anticipate it's going to get even hotter. And if you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen and I'm very much at home in the kitchen."




In Tuesday night's Democratic debate, Clinton bobbled a question about illegal immigrants getting driver's licenses in New York, appearing to both support the idea and later distance herself from it. Her campaign responded with a video showing each of her male candidates zeroing in on her. And at Wellesley College on Thursday, she said the school had prepared her for "the all-boys-club of presidential politics."

(Little more than a week ago, she curiously noted that winning the Iowa caucuses might prove difficult for her because the Hawkeye State had never elected a woman governor or senator.)

It was an unusual moment for a campaign that has banked on women voters while insisting that Clinton's own experience transcends gender. But while she portrays herself as strong, experienced and able to exact change, her opponents say she is playing the victim. And her remarks on gender seemed to open up a new vein of attack.

Most pointed was from Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.), who took her to task on the "Today" show Friday, noting that he didn't complain when the first several questions at a previous debate placed him in the cross hairs.

"I didn't come out and say, 'Look, I'm being hit on because I look different from the rest of the folks on the stage,'" Obama said. "We're not running for the president of the city council. We're running for the president of the United States of America."

His campaign manager, David Plouffe, used the gender flap as a reason to bring up the issue of secrecy. He issued a fundraising appeal that slammed Clinton for not releasing her White House records from her eight years as first lady. "It's time to turn the page on this kind of secrecy and restore trust in our government," he wrote.

Former Sen. John Edwards' campaign trumpeted a video accusing her of "the politics of parsing" and "double talk." It featured Clinton deflecting the question about driver's licenses for illegal immigrants, as well as seeming to say one thing and then another on the Iraq war.

Even the Republicans weighed in.

"The Clinton campaign goes so far in relying upon her being a strong, strong woman . . . and then on a dime, they can switch to say, 'Oh my goodness, the men are ganging up on her,'" former Sen. Fred Thompson of Tennessee told ABC News. "You can't have that both ways in American politics, and they're just beginning to find that out."

Former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney released an ad accusing Clinton of never having run so much as a corner store. "She hasn't run a state. She hasn't run a city," he said. "She has never run anything. And the idea that she could learn to be president as an internship doesn't make any sense."

But here in New Hampshire, where Clinton spent the last two days campaigning, questions about her candidacy seemed remote.

"Most people in New Hampshire were watching the replay of the Red Sox victory parade in Boston, not watching the presidential debate," said Kathy Sullivan, Clinton's state co-chairwoman. "I guess it's expected that at some point, there are people who are going to say, 'Let's see if we can make this more of a race than it is.'"

At the Red Arrow diner in Manchester, Michelle Trumble, a 3rd-grade teacher and independent voter, waited excitedly to shake Clinton's hand.

"There's always been a man running the country and it's time for a woman," she said, praising Clinton for overcoming obstacles that other women could not. "It's just a feeling I have about her. Anything would be better than what we have now."

And during visits to Crackskulls Coffee and Books, as well as the diner, voters asked Clinton about health care and education, not the debate.

"If there was ever a campaign prepared to deal with a bump in the road, certainly it's Sen. Clinton's," said Ray Buckley, the New Hampshire Democratic chairman.

Matt Bennett, a co-founder of the Democratic think tank Third Way, said it's not clear whether the charges against Clinton will stick.

"She had one tough debate, but that does not a major stumble make," he said, adding that she needs to find a better way to deal with it. "I don't think she needs 'the boys are being mean to me' story line. I think she needs to put her head down and keep plugging."

At a rally on the front lawn of the state Capitol, Clinton appeared to be doing just that, pointedly noting what a "pleasant change" it is to have a roster of Democratic candidates that voters can feel proud of.

"We don't have to be against anybody," she said.

And she told reporters that it might be good to have a president who is capable of dealing with nuance and complexity.

"I will continue to say what I believe, and sometimes it may not be as artfully presented as I would wish," she said. "But I think some of the challenges facing our country and some of the difficult issues we have to grapple with are not so easily answered within a 15-second hand raise or sound bite."

----------

jzuckman@tribune.com

Apparently "All Whites are Racist"

Sorry guys, I have been kind of on a racist kick today. I keep looking back at my previous post and its not what I wanted it to be. I cant seem to find the right words to explain how I am feeling about racism. I definately wish I hadnt spent the whole day with it on my mind either. But sitting here with nothing to do but Google things...I came across a very interesting article...how is this not just as bad, if not worse than what Dog did????

Racism still exists. Get over it people.


Why is everyone so shocked that Dog uses the "N" word? OMG...the forbidden "N" word. Racism still exists. Though some people would like to think it does not. One slip of the tongue and now the whole country is reminded that white people dont like--or arent supposed to-or have to pretend to like black people.

The thing everyone is missing here is that Dog was having a PRIVATE, that's right PRIVATE conversation with his son. Racism still exists. It just exists PRIVATELY because it is not politically correct to be racist.

Politically correct? What does that really mean anyways?

Definition:

deliberately avoiding offense: relating to or supporting the use of language or conduct that deliberately avoids giving offense, e.g. on the basis of ethnic origin or sexual orientation


The key word. AVOIDS. Avoidance is like a disease in itself. People avoid admitting racism exists in this day and age.

Racism is alive and kicking in this country. This instance further proves that. Dog will publically be burned at the stake for not being politically correct. He will then try to do everything to save his career/public image. Dog I have to let you know, you could go out and have an orgy with 10 black women...then let the sex tape get "leaked" on the internet and you will still not recover from this. Go ahead and have photo ops with as many black people as possible to try and recover your public image. Go ahead and be fake. Because now you have already shown us you are a biggot and now you will just set out to prove to us that you arent one and think that we wont see right through to your hidden agenda. In fact just now I was searching and searching to find a picture of you in some mixed racial company on the internet and I came up short... :(

Racism exists privately. End of story. This conversation existed privately between Dog and his son. That should have been the end of that story. Racism will never die. Though it should die, bringing this kind of attention to the issue certainly does not help racism become a non-issue.




-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
'Bounty Hunter' Suspended Over Slur in Phone Call
Associated Press
Friday, November 2, 2007; Page C07


HONOLULU, Nov. 1 -- A&E cable network has suspended production of its hit reality series "Dog the Bounty Hunter" after star Duane "Dog" Chapman repeatedly used a racial slur during a private phone conversation with his son that was recorded and posted online.

Chapman issued a statement Wednesday apologizing for the comments after the National Enquirer posted a clip of the conversation in which he uses a racial epithet six times in reference to his son's girlfriend.

Duane "Dog" Chapman apologized for making a racial slur in a private phone conversation with his son. (Lucy Pemoni - AP)

"We take this matter very seriously," A&E spokesman Michael Feeney said in a statement Thursday. "Pending an investigation, we have suspended production on the series. When the inquiry is concluded, we will take appropriate action."

"There's no problem with how the tape was obtained and Dog has acknowledged its authenticity and admitted to using the racist language," said David Perel, the Enquirer's editor in chief.

Perel declined to comment on how the tape was obtained. He said that isn't an issue because all that matters is what's on the tape.

In a statement, the 54-year-old Chapman said: "I did not mean to add yet another slap in the face to an entire race of people who have brought so many gifts to this world. I am ashamed of myself and I pledge to do whatever I can to repair this damage I have caused.

"My sincerest, heartfelt apologies go out to every person I have offended for my regrettable use of very inappropriate language. I am deeply disappointed in myself for speaking out of anger to my son and using such a hateful term in a private phone conversation."

Chapman said the clip was taken out of context.

"I was disappointed in his choice of a friend, not due to her race, but her character," he said. "However, I should have never used that term."

Chapman's show was in its fifth season and is one of A&E's top-rated programs. The series follows Chapman and his tattooed crew as they track down bail jumpers in Hawaii and other states.

Personality and its Role on Productivity in the University Student

Abstract
University students were examined to discover if one personality type over another was more productive in attaining higher education. This was examined using a personality inventory and a two-factor productivity scale. Twenty-two participants were given a personality inventory, demographic survey, and a number of tasks to complete. The ESTJ personality type was expected to be more productive than the other 15 personality types on the basis that ESTJ types are goal oriented, are interested in grades, and have a need to succeed. The results, however, proved to be insignificant. Interestingly though, the most productive group was very similar to the ESTJ personality type.


Take your personality test here.

Personality and its Role on Productivity in the University Student



Six hundred thousand students leave four year universities annually without receiving degrees (Porter, 2002). This means that six hundred thousand students per year give or take a few due to unforeseen causes, are finding university life unpleasant and are not being productive college students. Studies conducted by Cattell and Eysenck indicate that academic success is more attributed to personality type than intelligence (as cited in Sanchez, Rejano, & Rodriguez, 2001). According to Kathy Quinn (1999), people who are sensing-perceiving on the MBTI (Myers-Briggs Type Indicator) are historically unsuccessful in higher education ventures. However, several portraits of the ESTJ type seem to represent a model college student and therefore it seems the ESTJ personality type would fair better and be more production in higher education.


For example,
As young adults, they focus on their goals, both personal and professional. They build on education and career goals set earlier in life and do all that they can to make these goals become a reality. They seem to have less confusion or difficulty than some types in choosing a career or selecting a mate because they like focusing and making decisions (Hirsch & Kummerow).
In accordance the Portrait of an ESTJ (2000), states that ESTJ’s are take-charge people, with a tendency to focus in on details, and the put valiant effort into all that they are involved with. Following these definitions of an ESTJ, the most productive university student fits the profile of an ESTJ. These students complete their degrees at four year universities in a timely manner because they possess the ESTJ profile.



A description of each aspect of the ESTJ student is as follows: Extravert students like to speak freely with others about their ideas, work in groups, and enjoy variety and action in the classroom; Sensing students are creatures of tradition, use established approaches to problem solving, and work steadily; Thinking students prefer personal achievement, need to succeed, want to know the how’s and why’s of things, are interested in grades, and may actually like lectures; Judging students turn work in on time, have good study habits, and like to make decisions (UMIST Staff Development, n.d.). All of these traits wrapped into one personality type would lead to a successful college student.



Erlendsson (2001) states, “Productivity measurement isn’t an exact science.” The obstacle to tackle is how to measure the productivity of university students. (Hosseini, n.d.) implies that productivity is measured and defined by student learning. He also points out that academic schedules are much too often planned according to personal convenience rather than academic reasoning, and this leads to students spending more time and years in pursuit of a college degree (Hosseini, n.d.). Productivity, therefore, is down across college campuses. One of the reasons for the drop in productivity is because of the Information Age, and productivity being more an important outcome of school rather than during school (Erlendsson, 2001).



For the purpose of this research productivity will have two definitions since it is so hard to define. The first being productivity means the success of the university student (as in amount of learning) determined by a ratio of the number of years they have completed in higher education divided by the number of years they have been in the higher education system working toward a degree. This should provide an accurate picture of how the student is spending their time while attaining higher education. The second definition of productivity will deal with a timed task based productivity scale. The scale will use a ratio of how many tasks were successfully completed out of the total number of tasks available to complete. These two definitions of productivity should create a balance and give a fair judgment of the students’ actual productivity. Using this productivity scale should give an accurate measure of how personality affects scholastic productivity. Using productivity to determine the successfulness of students will help further the evidence provided which indicates that the ESTJ university students are more equipped to be successful university students, therefore it is expected that ESTJ students are more productive than the other 15 personality types indicated by the MBTI.


Method



Participants



Twenty-two junior and senior undergraduate psychology majors enrolled in Research Methods and Psychological Statistics classes at Georgia Southern University took part in the study. Four males and 18 females from the estimated ages of 18-24 took part in the study. All participation was strictly volunteered. Course credit as well as extra credit for participating in the experiment was given. Participation required approximately 15 minutes. All participants were treated ethically and fairly by the experimenter.



Materials



The timed task to determine the first aspect of productivity included students completing a sheet of 50 simple addition and subtraction problems with a time limit of three minutes to complete the task. For this portion of the experiment a stop watch or clock was needed to time the participants. The number of tasks completed successfully will be divided by the number of possible tasks, yielding the result of one as a perfect score on the timed task. The score on this task based scale was then added to the score on the demographic survey explained below.
Personality type was determined by the MBTI. This test is designed to group people into 16 possible personality types. These personality types can be out of the following categories: extraverts vs. introverts (E vs. I), sensers vs. intuitives (S vs. I), thinking vs. feeling (T vs. F), and perceivers vs. judgers (P vs. J). These types were theorized by Carl Jung which then led to the development of the MBTI (Argyle, 2000). The MBTI is a very widely used and excepted form of personality prediction. It is used across many disciplines which is why it works well in this study. Participants were given a short version (68 questions) of the personality test (Personality Test, 2003).



A four question demographic survey was used to determine the second aspect of productivity. Two questions were asked about the participants GPA (grade point average) and the participant’s gender. These questions were just for general information and were not used to calculate the results of the study. The other two questions provided the information needed to calculate the productivity aspect explained below. The number of years they have been in school is defined by the actual years and the number of years they have completed is determined by class rank. Freshman receive a year score of one, sophomores two, juniors three, and seniors four. So, for example, Bobby has been attending college since 1999 and he is a sophomore. His productivity score would be 0.4. This formula allowed for a score of one to be perfect productivity, therefore a score of one is the most productive. This score was added to the task productivity score explained above, yielding productivity scores ranging from 0-2, with 2 being the highest available score attainable.



Procedure
Participants in which volunteered for the study arrived at their specified time and room number. They seated themselves and were given their informed consent. The participants then signed the sign-in sheet to ensure they would receive either course credit or extra credit for volunteering to participate in the study. The participants were then given the 50 simple addition and subtraction problems face down and instructed to complete as many of the problems as they could in the given time limit of three minutes. The clock was started and participants turned over the sheet of paper containing the tasks and began the problems. Time was called after exactly three minutes and the participants were instructed to stop writing and turn the paper over.



The next segment in the experiment was for the participants to fill out the personality survey. The participants were encouraged to answer the questions to the best of their ability and answer all 68 questions to ensure accurate results. The results from the personality survey then assigned them into their group. All participants were given the same personality inventory, therefore all participants had an equal and fair chance to be assigned to their correct personality group as assigned by the personality inventory.



After the personality test was completed individually, the experimenter then gave the participants the demographic survey. They were instructed to answer honestly and completely all four questions. After this last segment was completed, the participants were then instructed to fold all three items together and turn them in. In exchange for the three items from the participants, the experimenter gave them a written debriefing statement explaining the purpose of the experiment and what their participation might help researchers learn. The participants were thanked and then released.



Results



The data were analyzed using a one-way between groups analysis of variance, with the level of alpha set at .05. The mean productivity throughout the eight levels of the independent variable, personality type, was 1.45 (SD=.24) with N=22. There was no significant difference between the independent variables (personality type) with respect to the dependent variable (productivity) with F (7, 14) =.809. As shown in Table 1, however, the personality group with the highest mean productivity was ENFP (extraverted-intuitive-feeling-perceiver) with 1.66 (SD=.36) with n=2. The personality group with the lowest productivity was INTP (introverted-intuitive-thinking-perceiver) with 1.15 (SD=0) with n=1. More people had the ESTJ and ISFJ (introverted-sensers-feeling-judging) personality types than any of the other levels of the independent variable with an n=5, respectively the groups had means of 1.41 (SD=.24) and 1.36 (SD=.22) The INTJ (introverted-intuitive-thinking-judging) group had a mean of 1.40 (SD=.04) with n=2, the ENFJ (extraverted-intuitive-feeling-judging) group had a mean of 1.49 (SD=.16) with n=3, the ESFJ (extraverted-senser-feeling-judging) group had a mean of 1.63 (SD=.34) with n=3, and the INFP (introverted-intuitive-feeling-perceiver) group had a mean of 1.44 (SD=0) with n=1.



Discussion



Although no significant effects were found for personality type, there were some interesting results that came out of the data. The two most prevalent personality types which showed up in the data were the ESTJ and the ISFJ groups. Both groups were below the mean for productivity although. Since only psychology majors were involved in the experiment you could say that these two personality types, though not on the highly productive side of things, could be correlated with the psychology profession. The ESTJ group was hypothesized to be the most productive group in the experiment, and even though it was not it is interesting that it was tied to be the most prevalent group in the study.



Also interesting is the fact that the most productive group was the ESFJ group, which is almost identical to the ESTJ group except in the feeling-thinking category. This could be again because the sample was limited to psychology majors; many of the people have chosen psychology as a career because they are feelers instead of thinkers.



Two of the groups in the data, INFP and INTP, held only one participant. For this reason the data collected here is not entirely sufficient. If more participants had shown up in this group, then the data might be able to reflect more of the entire population of university students. However, having at least 8 out of the 16 possible personality types showing up in the data was surprisingly good for such a small sample.



On that note, the insufficient sample size and the narrow choice of possible subjects for the study did not accurately portray how personality actually affects productivity. If a researcher were to try and replicate this study, suggestions would be as follows: have a broader range of university students from different majors and all in all a larger sample size to ensure representatives from each personality type.



On the topic of productivity, as noted in the research by Erlendsson (2001), measuring productivity is a hard thing to do. For this reason, it makes coming up with a good scale very intimidating. Using the math problems has advantages as well as disadvantages. One reason being some students are better at math than others no matter what their personality type is. A better task based scale should be used in further research or use of something to balance this extraneous variable out would be efficient.



In summary, this research provides an interesting look into what personality type makes a productive university student. Although, the data proved to have no significance, some interesting information stood out concerning what personality types are most prevalent in the major of psychology and the fact that the group which was hypothesized to be more productive than the other groups had only one small difference to the group which proved to be the most productive in the sample, however, with no significance.

References



Argyle, M. (2000). The effect of personality. In Psychology and Religion An Introduction (chap 3, pp.30-46). New York: Routledge.
Erlendsson, J. (2001). Productivity: Measurement problems. Educational Productivity. (Online). Retrieved October 12, 2004 from http://www.hi.is/~joner/eaps/wh_prodp.htm
Hirsch, S.K. & Kummerow, J. (n.d.). ESTJ-The Enforcer. (Online), Retreived September 29, 2004 from http://www.geocities.com/lifexplore/estj.htm
Hosseini, A. (n.d.) Definitions of Productivity As Used in Business, Hospital, and Academia a Summary. (Online), Retrieved October 12, 2004 from http://www.sonoma.edu/users/h/hosseini/productivity/Definition.html
Personality test center. (2003). Personality Test Center-Personality Types. (Online). Retrieved September 29, 2004 from http://www.personality test.net/cgi-bin/q.pl
Porter, K. (2003).The Value of a College Degree. ERIC Digest. (Online), Retrieved September 29, 2004 from http://www.ericdigest.org/2003-3/value.htm
Portrait of an ESTJ-Extraverted Sensing Thinking Judging(extroverted Thinking with Introverted Sensing. (Online), Retrieved September 29, 2004 from http://www.personalitypage.com/ESTJ.html
Quinn, K.S. (1999). A case study of four Sensing-Perceieving Myers-Briggs types who successfully completed college. Dissertation Abstracts International, 59(7-A), 2338. (AAM9841762). Retrieved from PSYCHinfo database September 29, 2004.
Sanchez, M.M., Rejano, E.I., & Rodriguez, Y.T. (2001). Personality and academic productivity in the university student. Social Behavior & Personality. 29(3), 299-306.
UMIST Staff Development. (n.d). EFFECTS Course: Learning Styles. (pp. 5). Retrieved September 29, 2004 from PSYCHinfo database.

Masculinity and Femininity: A Changing Perspective Over Eighty Years

Masculinity and Femininity: A Changing Perspective Over Eighty Years

Gender stereotypes have been around for hundreds of years. What it means to be masculine and what it means to be feminine has evolved and changed rapidly in the past several decades. Obviously, these stereotypes have had a great amount of influence upon psychological research. First is the problem of how to measure femininity and masculinity since the meaning of each term varies from population to population. However, here in the United States the struggle has been to find a definition for each term, so that it can be applied to research, this endeavor has proved to be very time consuming and misleading. In the beginning researchers believed that all males were masculine and all females were feminine and should innately want to possess these characteristics of their inborn sex, through further research and a change in attitudes it has come to the attention of many researchers that femininity and masculinity are not polar opposites, but yet lie on a continuum (Lips, 2005).

Beginning in the 1920s, it was thought that if you were a male then you were an extravert and if you were female, you were an introvert. Although researchers did admit on the basis of anima and animus that you could have a little of both femininity and masculinity that you could only find it if you dug deep into the psyche (Faithfull, 1927). The common notion of the era was that a male, simply for the fact that he was born a male, would possess certain personality characteristics. The gender roles were extremely rigid in this time and so researchers looked for ways to find differences in the sexes.

Miles and Terman also believed the sexes to be very different from one another. They wanted to find a way to measure these differences and from this point, they came up with scales of masculinity and femininity, thus reinforcing the two to be polar opposites. The research claimed not to be looking to be able to identify a strong man and a weak woman, however because of low numbers of women in the study the women’s average scores were brought down (Miles & Terman, 1929). A later study showed Miles and Terman trying to define masculinity and femininity with a scale (Miles & Terman, 1936). Criticisms of this scale say that femininity points were earned by ignorance and that masculinity points were earned by giving the correct answer. It said if you were male, you were intellectual and if you were female then you were not so bright (Lips, 2005). The notion in this era is still that females are feminine because of their sex and that males are masculine because of their sex. Miles & Terman acknowledge that some people do not quite fit this mold because of physiological reasons (1929). This era is still very big on males being the superior intellectual being.

Quite interesting is the fact that Miles was a woman herself. And it seems she at least embraced the idea that being female meant you were “feminine” and acted a certain way. She was a non-conformist by getting her education, but then you have to look at the male-based and oriented education she did receive. The Women’s Right’s movement was going strong in the 1920s and this reflects the research in psychology. A newspaper article read, “Identical rights for men and women…such a conception of womanhood contradicts all the facts of physiology, psychology, economics, and social science (Regan, 1924).” This further reinforces the attitude of the era that major differences between the sexes exist and that there is no room for a mixture of masculinity and femininity within one human being.

Moving down the timeline to 1946, Weston La Barre has some interesting ideas about femininity and masculinity. Women and femininity is now valued as a consumer and above all else femininity is valued in attractiveness. A man that is overly attractive or takes a job that displays that attractiveness, such as acting, is not being masculine enough. Whereas a woman who is not attractive enough or cannot use that attractiveness to sway her man to consume the goods produced by other men is not feminine enough. Weston looks at femininity and masculinity as a producer/consumer relationship (La Barre, 1946). This relationship is in itself is of the original power structure displayed in earlier decades, but now instead of intellect over ignorance it is producer over consumer. However, obviously in order to be a producer usually one must be intelligent, so it is rather a catch twenty-two. This displays that not much has changed and that masculinity and femininity are still viewed as polar opposites. However, Le Barre admits that these stereotypes of masculinity and femininity are hurting both sexes (1946). Which means that people are beginning to understand that there is no true definition of what is masculine and what is feminine.

In the 1960’s researchers were still trying to find a common definition for the study of masculinity and femininity because most researchers were still using the assumption that gender norms are fixed and constant (Lips, 2005). Karen Vroegh took to studying preschool children and her findings were consistent with the current male/female stereotypes (1968). The most masculine boys were found to be extraverted whereas the most feminine girls were found to be introverted (Vroegh, 1968). This was congruent with Faithfull’s research on the topic (1927). Vroegh’s research admitted that there were variances in masculinity and femininity within their assigned sex (1968). Therefore, the attitude is moving toward a continuum, but it is still putting the sexes at opposite ends of the spectrum. The conclusion is that femininity and masculinity cannot be defined in such a way that would generalize the concepts across time and age and culture. The issue is also brought up that these characteristics end up being mostly male/female because of socialization. The stereotype sticks because of socialization and what is socially appropriate for a male/female to act like (Vroegh, 1968).

The research from the 1960s helped to further convince researchers that a definitive answer to what was masculinity and femininity was far out of reach or maybe impossible. Instead of giving up the researchers of the 1980s turned their focus on the definition of femininity and masculinity to be something self-reflective. Richard Coan worked to further the knowledge on this new way to look at femininity and masculinity. As stated by Coan, “As we commonly think of them in psychological theory and research, neither masculinity or femininity is a unitary trait, and the two in combination cannot be adequately conceptualized as the opposite poles on a single continuum (1989, p. 817).” Although his results came out with the same stereotypical traits associated with each concept of masculinity and femininity, the findings further supported the notion that masculinity and femininity are socialized concepts based on time and culture (Coan, 1989). The self-reporting method of researching these concepts adds to the full body of research that divided the concepts into opposite concepts. The self-reporting method marks the beginning of a bridge between masculinity and femininity. Coan being an anthropologist based a lot of his research on Jung’s principles of logos and ergos (1989). And if Jung’s theories are true then femininity and masculinity have never been “naturally” divided by being born of either sex.

Fast forward to 2001 and the work of Rebecca Glover reveals that masculinity and femininity are know grouped together and called “gender role” and are declared separate than personality traits. The research was to find out if masculinity and femininity had anything to do with moral orientation. The answer proved to be that no gender roles had less to do with moral orientation than other personality traits (Glover, 2001). The implications of this research show that no matter what you score on the masculinity/femininity scales whether you are male or female that does not have a lot to do with your moral reasoning. This is a huge step forward by separating personality from gender role and sex. Furthermore, a woman with a masculine gender role does not have a moral reasoning affected by her gender role. Glover does not come out and say that masculinity and femininity are on a continuum instead of polar opposites, however, the Bem Sex Role Inventory was used in her study (Glover, 2001). This inventory was the first to make masculinity and femininity two separate entities allowing people to score a variety of scores on each entity (Lips, 2005).

In conclusion, the way that masculinity and femininity has been studied over the past eighty years has changed a lot. It has gone from two separate concepts to one concept on a single continuum. It is now called gender role and your personality is now separate from that instead of your gender role dictating your personality. The stereotypes still exists, but it is a lot easier for one to break those stereotypes and step out of what is supposed to be normal for their sex. It is a lot easier for women to step outside these boundaries than for men, because the gender roles for men have remained a lot more traditional and rigid than those for women.












References
Coan, R. (1989). Dimensions of masculinity and femininity: a self-report inventory. Journal of Personality Assessment, 53 (4), 816-826.
Faithfull, T.J. (1927). Bisexuality: an essay on extraversion and introversion. Oxford, England: Bale.
Glover, R.J. (2001). Discriminators of moral orientation: gender role or personality? Journal of Adult Development, 8 (1), 1-7.
La Barre, W. (1946). Social cynosure and social structure. Journal of Personality, 14 (3), 169-185.
Lips, H. (2005). Sex & Gender: An Introduction (5th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
Miles, C.C. & Terman, L.M. (1929). Sex differences in the association of ideas. American Journal of Psychology, 41 (2), 185-206.
Regan, A.(1924). Should women have identical rights with men? The Congressional Digest.
p. 204.
Vroegh, K. (1968). Masculinity and femininity in the preschool years. Child Development, 39, 1253-1257.